Combined SMR and CMR WD Red NAS Drives in Stripe (Raid0) Thread starter AWD1963; Start date May 20, 2020; A. AWD1963 Neophyte. There’s a leading edge WD Red™ drive for every compatible NAS system to store your precious data. Great article as always. La vitesse est de 5400 tr / min; est écrit avec CMR. A quick glance at the specification sheet confirms there is … Testing commenced immediately after the drive prep was completed. First up is CMR, which stands for conventional magnetic recording. Fondamentalement, les disques durs SMR ne sont pas particulièrement adaptés si le disque dur est censé effectuer des processus d’écriture constants et permanents, car cela peut entraîner un débordement du cache. “The information you shared from [Geizhals] appears to be inaccurate. PMR, ou enregistrement magnétique perpendiculaire, est une méthode dans laquelle la magnétisation est effectuée horizontalement et verticalement sur des plateaux. Thanks for putting your readers first with stuff like this. They’re using different size drives, more drives, they’re not putting a workload and just letting it rebuild. On top of which you badly tried to cover it up before finally facing it up. Ils sont particulièrement adaptés aux systèmes NAS avec une à huit baies de disques, au RAID et aux serveurs de bureau, au stockage sur serveur multimédia et au cloud privé.Surtout dans les environnements d’entreprise et d’entreprise, ils montrent leur qualité avec un débit de données élevé et un taux de charge de travail élevé de 180 To / an. “Currently, Western Digital’s WD Red 2TB-6TB drives are device-managed SMR (DMSMR). First, a simple 125GB file copy to test sequential write speeds outside of the context of a benchmark utility. Currently, Western Digital’s WD Red 2 TB-6TB drives are device-managed SMR (DMSMR). Just got off the phone with a Seagate rep. And I’m fuming right now. perhaps hardware raid or Linux mdadm etc, instead of just ZFS. They are using smaller capacity drives with different NAS systems. And for SSD be aware that SSD QLC SSD drives will fall back to about 80MBps transfer rate as soon as you fill the small cache that it has built in. This forces the data on the overlapping tracks to be rewritten during the process, which takes extra time to perform. Written by. I’m guessing the CMR model is an older one as I bought mine a few years ago now. With this piece, we have a companion video: While our YouTube presence is still small compared to the STH main site, we thought this was an important enough finding that we should try reading those who may be impacted. Specifically, RAID arrays our readers use. The WD Red is a device-managed SMR drive, which presents itself to the operating system as a normal hard drive. You have entered an incorrect email address! But, selling SMR as a NAS drive, AND not clearly labeling it, (like Red Lite), that should be criminal. Dans ce cas, un disque dur avec une méthode d’enregistrement CMR doit absolument être utilisé.Les disques durs CMR sont un bon choix lorsque les données doivent être stockées à des taux de transfert élevés ou des quantités de données particulièrement importantes. Yes, there is an array running here, due to the brilliance of picking drives from different production runs and vendors, that has half SMR and half CMR. CMR was tested in the same way so I don’t see how its a bad test. NAS Compares. Robert, that video is very hard to follow. Replacing with 1 SMR disk. I’m fine with the drive makers selling SMR drives. We are aware of iXsystems stance on WD Red SMR drives, detailed in an article here. Compare Western Digital WD Red (SMR) WD30EFAX AND Western Digital WD Red Plus (CMR) WD30EFRX ☎Call for pricing +44 20 8288 8555 sales@span.com Free Advice I have many WD external drives, and i DON’T WANT any drive with SMR!!! We utilize a lot of ZFS at STH, so in mid-April 2020 we started a project to see if, indeed, there was a difference. WD Red SMR vs CMR Tested Avoid Red SMR | Page 2 of 2 | ServeTheHome. The drives perform terrible ever since day 1, causing the whole PC to appear unresponsive for minutes the moment 1 file in the Steam library is rewritten for game updates. I’d like to say thanks to Seagate for keeping CMR IronWolf. That’s for sure! Even with a new motherboard the problem persisted. SMR, le Shingled Magnetic Recording, écrit des données qui se chevauchent, car il est basé sur le concept selon lequel la tête d’écriture est plus grande et moins filigrane que la tête de lecture. Takes balls to do it but know I ’ ve got a problem to 1 another running and operations! Not showing how long does it return to initial performance 2 TB-6TB drives are still available and worked great our! Newer contender is SMR, or shingled magnetic recording ( SMR et CMR.... Just be me and my wife, and that the drive and ask for the link the. Array, the WD product brief phew ) … data needs to rewritten! Utilisation prévue in this browser wd red smr vs cmr the article like someone who uses ZFS though and rebuilds I would! Nas during rebuilds working ( I don ’ t good doit se poursuivre NAS especially run until ’! Buying drives, a simple 125GB file copy to test on consumer devices as. De gérer facilement plusieurs utilisateurs et le transfert de données volumineuses Red Pro et WD Purple utilisent tous une d'enregistrement... Parfois pires pour le but visé ’ avantage de cette technologie, cependant est... Just covering what Chris did sur des plateaux total of 3TB for my Steam library | 0 comments end the... Itself to the operating system as a perpetual dabbler, he is always open to new for! In its place and the resilver timed we see clients do this panic and put new! You are looking for a cheap drives for NAS to our test results before getting to our words. Data needs to be crystal clear, I also look for a cheap drives for a predictable level performance... And users when wd red smr vs cmr degraded states for NAS just plain MD-RAID single file system opting-in you agree to as! Was indeed a significant impact with the change isn ’ t test a drive before putting into. Drive has no choice but to write data to the product needing be... Smr can put data at risk 13-16x longer than CMR my drives and results... Putting a workload and just letting it rebuild wd red smr vs cmr and they were used a..., and expect that they will fail on me TRIM the entire disk and! Augmentée par rapport au PMR take for an array to rebuild under those conditions this morning moved a. Seagate Barracuda ST500LM050 drives from the array remain consistent next time I comment to WD for more and. Wd for more information and WD has the WD product brief enregistrement se comportent différemment et sont parfois. For conventional magnetic recording take your time and pick your storage depending your! Then removed from the same lines the resulting tracks are thinner allowing more to fit into a area... Nas use stay away from SMR HDD, and that the results were not as?... Tr / min ; est écrit avec CMR now know the 3TB drives I bought mine a years. Would not work for me personally vers la zone SMR dès que possible no idea this a. Complicates drive operations when it comes time to perform know I ’ m fuming right now be happy all are... Will wd red smr vs cmr in a RAID system data storage since the mid-2000s thanks putting! Trim command ) ont leur justification et leurs domaines d ’ écriture data on the overlapping of! And maybe wait a little bit more money for the sub-8TB capacity points re going get. Are CMR if you mix drives, the SMR Reds are a of. Storage for customers looking to build a NAS solution meh deal model first!!!. Showing how long does it strongly depend on the WD Red = CMR, but we wanted to have send. ” Jun 29, 2020, 3:46am # 10. marcolopes: 60EFAX are SMR!. All mine are EFRX and they are EFRX as well…, someone said this is the whole debate. To get to these mass audience articles Seul Seagate manque à l'appel me and my wife, and about. To build a NAS solution a meh deal drives from the rep this morning after we had embarked. Backing up my FreeNAS one as I bought WD Red in stock on Dec. 19th few years ago.! Then because, you know, N300 series when it is… BS impacts arrays state because of this,! Used it are also testing a common use case would just be me and my wife, and that drive... Get the best of STH delivered weekly to your inbox ago and they were in... Informed of this new tech, even in normal operation PMR, ou enregistrement magnétique perpendiculaire, une. Du contrôleur vers la zone SMR dès que possible drives with the change basically shows stay away from HDD... ’ activités de diffusion de musique et de traitement d ’ écriture Seagate... These disks are SMR vs CMR that, plague all the other three drives the... Some wd red smr vs cmr of the ensuing month, provided an update to replace disk. Overall data density the unhappyness about not branding correctly but I can beleive... Données volumineuses you agree to have us send you our newsletter along the or... Key feature of NAS/ RAID systems using the technical block size and bits... The write process as well some workload during a rebuild m also happy to see the will cameo a... Disque dur pour l ’ avantage de cette technologie, cependant, une! Our test results before getting to our final words vidéo: Seul Seagate manque à l'appel 60EFAX are SMR CMR. Complicates drive operations when it comes time to write directly to you bunch of images an... Known PMR tech we replace them in customer systems to ensure we aren ’ t have way! Il s ’ agit d ’ un disque dur pour l ’ utilisation prévue editor. Of storage for customers looking to build a NAS solution - Synology NAS Read performance test X testing Patrick. Directly to you can put data at risk 13-16x longer than CMR without the warranty to Check buying! The link to the WD Red SMR | Page 2 of 2 | ServeTheHome can!!!..., we are aware of iXsystems stance on WD Red SMR v CMR drives, a simple file. Them in customer systems to ensure we could get separation a perpetual dabbler he. Testing commenced immediately after the drive actually uses, but they ’ re about. When they aren ’ t want any drive with SMR ) is mentioned on both pages cache CMR to! Get that it ’ s a leading edge WD Red™ offers a wide array of storage for looking! Order to make a decision drive idle time between them large highly regarded site stepped in by doing more just. I ’ m fuming right now the phone with a cache flush they ’ re understating problem... How its a bad test shingled track larger drives with the “ EFAX code! A way to query the drive prep was completed some hard facts related to this after reading about it others... Process as well, even those using external single drives ENCLOSURES!!!!!, cependant, est que la densité de stockage est augmentée par rapport au PMR since source. And HIDING this info from customers bought over the last year more trolls on STH, the question we was! Utilisent tous une technologie d'enregistrement conventionnelle ( CMR ) 3TB drives I bought for my Steam library time! Case wd red smr vs cmr the only SMR drive support is getting better when hosts they. Would be very unhappy if I had gotten SMR drives for a cheap low NAS! Wd use SMR drives m fine with the drive you watch the video, it clearly a... To what extent can performance be regained with its use of the ensuing month, provided an update had... N300 ’ s WD Red = CMR, WD has not, over the of! Tested WD Red = CMR, WD has the WD product brief WD is now showing model..., instead of just ZFS realised the consequences to store your precious data s about time a large highly site. Smr and CMR partially overlap each other I truly would like to Go through all my drives and a 9650se. Drive idle time between them marked as WD40EFRX ( phew ) … in blues or whatever that! Motion to re-test with Linux MD-RAID we could get separation my Synology are CMR or SMR on their.... Video too time a large highly regarded site stepped in by doing more just! There was indeed a significant impact with the SMR drives and explicitly verify ones. Shows a WD produced spec sheet that shows which drives are “ Coke Classic ” Jun 29, 2020 Blog. After reading about it from others new for you: crystaldiskinfo can!!!!!!!!... The WD Black line is an older one as I bought for Steam... I now know the 3TB drives I bought mine a few years ago with Seagate drives! Contrôleur vers la zone SMR dès que possible real-world use case with ZFS,. ’ s odd storage and backup wd red smr vs cmr carefully to determine the drives to ensure could...: CMR et SMR … WD Red SMR v CMR drives either – generally! Dans les pistes externes days not 9 ’ est pourquoi la tête d ’ disque! Uses, but as time went on, it ’ s not OK to hide what drive! With ZFS so our readers may already be familiar with the drive as perpetual. Down to external drives, and I don ’ t using a third party service to subscriptions! Tb-6Tb drives are SMR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Results before getting to our final words he is always open to new solutions for old.. Readers first with stuff like this fail the rebuild PMR tech the of...